Just Watchin'
.
=== Good Pitching Beats Good Hitting ===
... except when it doesn't. Dave Fleming, at BJOL, goes over the four Division Series matchups to see if Good Pitching won. He's not trying to prove a case in a court of law. He's just cracking peanuts, and watching baseball. ... Of the Final Eight teams, in four matchups, how many qualified as Pitching vs Hitting matchups?
NYY vs BAL: both teams had 109 ERA's. NYY had a far better offense. No test case here. The better team squeaked out a win.
.....
A's vs DET: both teams had ERA's of 114 and 112, and both had OPS's of 97-104. Fleming called Oakland the pitching team and Detroit the hitting team, saying that hitting beat pitching. I'd call it a non-test case.
.....
SF vs CIN: Huge test case. Did you realize that the Reds had an ERA+ of 127 ?! And they had a lousy OPS+ of 90 also, despite Votto, Bruce, Phillips and Ludwick. San Fran, on the other hand, had an excellent offense and below-average pitching.
The Giants won, so that's an In Yo Face against the purists.
.....
Gnats vs Cards: the Montreal Expos had a sky-high ERA+ of 119. The Expos' offense was league average; the Cards' offense was better than their defense. Legit test case.
The Cardinals, the hitting team, won -- staging a huge comeback against a terrific closer. In Yo Face.
.