Scouting On Site
Super-NPB-Poster Taro sees Tanaka as an impact starter in the majors, "but on the Kuroda, Iwakuma level" rather than on the Yu Darvish level. Taro recommends Kenta Maeda as a more cost-efficient choice, capable of pitching at 90% the success level for 30% of the price.
IceBreakerX, who also lives in Japan, says not so fast on Maeda. He's quite short, as was Ian Snell for instance, and much more of a roll of the dice. Though a worthy roll.
Dr D's quick takes?
............
Check out this super-slo-mo of Maeda-san's delivery. The first pitch is normal speed, but the second one is at 1:10 tempo.
Point A: Maeda has a Lincecum-class leap towards the plate -- a truly preposterous crotch split that leaves him landing as far forward as, say, Doug Fister.
A small RHP's main disadvantage is that his fastball is "short" -- that is, the arm action, body action, spin on the ball, etc., triggers the batter's brain to time the pitch as (say) 94 MPH. But because it is thrown from 1-2 feet farther away, it creates a type of "hanging fastball" effect as it "slows down" on its way to the plate. Erasmo Ramirez has to battle this problem.
Tim Lincecum did not battle this problem. His fastball, already fast, was also "sneaky fast" because it traveled such a short distance.
Maeda's landing spot is a very important secret weapon, and it translates beautifully to the majors. In fact Dr. D would opine that the effect is amplified in the majors, because Japanese hitters are not greedy and do not overswing.