And JeDi answered. Heck no, I won't trade for Ichiro.
Ok, truly you have to take what you know Ichiro produced which included an 8 WAR rookie year and 9 WAR Hits record season that also included a singles record probably less likely to ever be broken. But I'm ok with a new story this time too. Seager has been great but he didn't come up like this. The last one that truly did for the Ms was...Ichiro I guess but different scenario. So I'll say he lacked the power and eye to move before that. With all the skills comparable? Wait, who ever, honestly? We can talk about Griffey and his .748 OPS. Alvin Davis did very well but not nearly the speed. So far Maniger is next tier but I'm not certain he stays there. Kenji Johjima probably belongs in the top 5 of Ms Rookie hitting seasons. Very good chances we're talking about the second best rookie Ms hitting performance ever. Can he unseat Ichiro and the .350 BA?
How about they're Shoeless Joe and Vean Gregg? Eh, Lynn and Rice work just fine, but if they'd had Ty Cobb hitting .420 that year they wouldn't have been 1 and 3 in MVP. Just saying.