1
Matt,
I wouldn't have a problem with signing Branyan for 2 years. My position is based on the premise that it is unlikely that Branyan is going to settle for a 2-year deal, (3rd year buyout), if he continues having a career year.
The 1B/DH issue remains valid -- but I'd happily surrender a little flexibility in that regard to put a short-term producer firmly in place.
Should the club EXPLORE extending Branyan? Absolutely. I just believe they should also explore trading him. As to which route is better for the club -- that is ultimately determined by how good (or bad) the offers for him are, and how good (or bad) his contract demands might be.