Add new comment

In 2009:
Endy Chavez starting: 21-18
Wlad Balentien starting: 12-14
Of course, that really isn't fair to Wlad. Endy is hitting better than Wlad, (.663 OPS to .642).
While I'm perfectly willing to accept that modern defensive metrics leave a ton to be desired, the wisdom from scouts all over the place assess Endy as one of the best and most versatile OF gloves around. I'm willing to accept that wisdom barring evidence to the contrary.
What I'm not willing to do is accept that Wlad's .279 OBP is better for the club than Endy's .323 OBP. I really don't care about Wlad's doubles. I'd rather 'settle' for Endy's extra walks AND extra SBs, (8 for 9 on the season).
Wlad is around because they continue to hope that he'll develop into a major league hitter. Thus far, there have been flashes ... but too few and too far between.
No, Endy is not a great hitter. But one thing Endy does is provide a league average OBP. THAT gives other hitters on the team extra chances. The offensive woes for the Ms aren't because of Endy -- they are because of the 4 starters hitting worse than Endy.