1
Gee...last year, people were all over me for proclaiming that Moyer hadn't actually been effective since 2004, but now that you need to make your case around 2004, it's OK to say he was not actually a good pitcher in 2008? How convenient. For you.
I agree that Moyer was not fundamentally different in 2008...but that does not mean the results didn't improve...they did...and they improved because he avoided mistakes more reguarly in high leverage moments. I wouldn't project anything positive based on 2008...but the season definitely paints a picture of a pitcher who lives and dies by consistency.