1
Agree... Both guys have trended up in recent years, but overall there probably isn't much seperating them ability-wise either than durability.
Barring a continued Gonzalez breakout or Pena washout, I just don't see much difference in the short-term.
This biggest difference between the two is the second bargain year for Gonzalez. It makes him legitimately much more valuable of a trade commodity, but the question is whether its worth the cost?
1B is going to be loaded next offseason like this year's 2B. A one-year guy could be pretty ideal.