1
After letting things sink in a little I think I prefer Montero's upside to Smoak's readiness.
Smoak's splits vs LHanders are a little troublesome and kind of cancel out his advantage in "safeness" a bit:
http://minorleaguesplits.com/cgi-bin/pl.cgi
Tex is excellent at both sides of the plate and this may be what seperates them.
That said, Smoak is still a beast and getting him from Texas is great extra bonus. Both are excellent specs.