Add new comment

Both guys crossed .900 OPS just twice before age 30 and hung out in the mid-.800s for most of those prime years.  Morneau has been a 37 2B / 31 HR bat with 68 walks per 162, and Tino was a 29 2B / 27 HR bat with 62 walks per 162.  If they're the "mid-800s in his prime" types then I have no problem adding that to my team. 
I expect that to be Smoak's level, between those two stat lines.  But Adrian Gonzalez is at 35 and 32 with 78 walks.  Fielder is at 32 and 37 with 89 walks.
The power numbers aren't changing from Morneau to A-Gone and Fielder - just the BBs. If Smoak can walk like Gonzalez and Fielder and Choo and hit 30/35, he's a monster.  If he walks like Tino and Morneau, then he will "merely" be a great lineup addition and future All-Star instead of one of the greatest hitters in the league.
In limited at-bats this year, here are Smoak's 162-game projections: 20 2B / 21 HR, 74 walks.  And that includes his "I don't remember how to take a walk" stint when he first got here.
I think he's a 30/30 man going forward, but he ALREADY looks to walk more than Tino and Morneau.  Which is a good thing...and gives a good shot of getting to that .900 OPS line more often, or at least making his floor projections that much higher.
~G