Add new comment

But he's getting close with us.
You and I have argued long and hard over Tui :) but I really do think he's got a shot to be a major league player for several years. 
He's just such an odd duck.  Huge kid, very athletic, not a good fielder at a glove position so he likely moves to LF or 1B, but the bat doesn't play well in LF or at 1B.  He's got a lot in common with Mangini and Liddi and Tenbrink and a host of other nominal 3B in the system.
If he can't play third, then he's got a long road ahead of him.  His Ks are out of control.  I was glad to see his eye come back - even improve - in Tacoma last year, but it didn't bring good results with it.  Hopefully it's an improvement he can maintain and will allow him to use that huge body of his to good effect. 
But I see him more as a Wily Mo Pena or Gabe Kapler sort.  Gabe had many mediocre years where you never quite got the power you expected from that ripped of a guy, and Pena could supply power but fell off the bandwagon with his swing and then fell apart.
Tui did weird things to his swing in AAA a couple years ago to get far more power out of it at the expense of a K every 2.8 ABs.
The Ks have stayed horrible in the bigs, but he's lost the power he sacrificed in the process.
He's got time to work it out still.  The kid's fairly young, can backup multiple (hopefully non-glove) positions, and by all accounts is a hard worker.
We'll see if it's enough.  I'd love him to be Jeff Conine, but if it works out that way I think it's somewhere else - unless he can start it this year.
We'll see if his suddenly-even 2010 batting eye from Tacoma is signal noise or the start of something for his time as a Mariner.
~G