1
Either guy should be able to produce offense equal to or better than Gutierrez. Saunders could do it by producing more power, Langerhans with OBP. Defensively, obviously, neither is Guti. But, in 2010, Guti wasn't even Guti, but he didn't make any errors, so that's something.
Saunders is probably the best upside potential offensively, so on an offense starved team I believe we're better off with him in CF than Gutierrez.