1
A lot of the guys around and above Ichiro on those lists are also known or suspected steroid users. I think that has to be taken into consideration.
Also, IIRC, some of the WAR formulas understate the value of baserunning, where Ichiro also excells.
OTOH, I also think that it needs to be taken into consideration that Ichiro in RF does block a position you can use for a power bat. Sure, his defensive value there is huge, but it does make it harder to find MOTO bats. This probably detracts from his overall value a little, despite the great consistent WAR numbers. Despite this, he's obviously a HOFer and I'm glad to have had the privilege of him on our team.
BTW, this CAPTCHA is torture.