Add new comment

So it's actually worse.  Choo, As-Cab, Lopez and even Betancourt were all gotten by the international guys, most of whom are still here.  They were not part of the scouts and farm directors Bavasi brought into the org.
I assume we're only doing bats here, so for Bavasi's guys you can still count Morse (who we got no use out of).  But it's astounding how in 5 years he couldn't find a bat to save his life.  Now, with the Brewers Jack didn't find a ton of pitching, but he hasn't shown any issues in that dept with us, while Bavasi found Tillman, JCR (again, international), Morrow and Pineda (international)...and not a lot else. 
Aumont, I guess, if you think he can make a go of it with his control issues.  He's still a year or more away. Tillman still hasn't done anything other than get shelled in the majors worse than Beavan or Furbush over multiple years (180 IP).  Ramirez isn't anyone and still has a couple years before he can even start thinking of being someone.
But whether with pitching or hitting, Bavasi found approximately one above-average player in each category domestically in his 5 years with the club.
Morrow and Jones.  That's essentially it.  The last draft by his farm directors, in 2008?  Fields, Raben, Pribanic, Hensley, Lorin, Tenbrink, Kasparek, Maurer...hey, Maurer!  Might eventually get a second arm to add to that list there.
It's astounding how bad they were in the domestic draft. 
Just look at the 2009 draft for comparison:
Z added Ackley (no brainer to me, but Clement was only one draft slot behind this one and we messed up that pooch pretty badly), Franklin, Seager, Catricala, Carraway, Moran, Gillheeney, Tony Vasquez...that's 3 guys who have already logged big-league time, one of whom is a star and the other hitter looking like a decent regular, with two top-100 hitting prospects arriving in AAA and the rest of the arms in the high minors with shots at a big league career.
If you offered me Morrow + Jones for that list headed by Ackley, I'd turn you down.  In one draft, Jack out-did Bavasi's 5.  Yowtch.
As Sandy said, there were problems in the types of players they were putting faith in in the first place, but it gets worse when you can't recognize useful talent even when you have it.  I'm just thankful we didn't manage to trade away Pineda as a throw-in to some other deal.
I'm sure it was a close call.
~G