1
I didn't say Fister was more dominant than Putz... I said he was more valuable. He has what... 5 years of club control? Durable, never injured (as Putz was). Demonstrating improvement, baseball Smartskins and guts. Cheap compared to Putz, and a good starter is more valuable than a reliever. So yeah, I think Fister is more valuable than Putz (partly because Putz was overvalued like most closers). Sure having a dominant closer is nice (if healthy) but honestly by war (not even war/$) I think Fister wins.