1
I get that he has tools Doc, but I still see a TON of errors and general mistakes on his defensive resume. If you're right and he's better defensively than his reputation suggests...(and that's entirely possible), then these comparisons are encouraging, but Brandon Inge would have been a below-replacement-level player if he hadn't been a +15 rrun defensive infielder in his prime. Gary Gaetti would have been somewhat useful, but no more so than, say, Ron Coomer or Dave Magadan if he didn't play good D as well as hit for occasional power. A utility infielder and that's all. All of your comps were tgood players...all of them were good to great fielders. IBIWISI with Liddi.