1
Pineda is a horse who could give you 200-plus innings for a decade. Even if he were a soft-tosser that would be worth a lot.
The idea of trading him and others for a couple years of Votto at non-bargain prices to fill a position that already has the team's best hope for legit power strikes me as daft. (Not as daft as the Giants trading Lincecum, but still . . . ) I think it makes Fielder look cheap.
And it creates as many problems as it solves. Odds are that at least one of Hultzen-Paxton-Walker will have his career shredded by injury. It's just the way it works. You can't trade away all the pitchers who've made it at least part way through their toughest injury-risk years.