1
Pineda is a rarer commodity than Votto? Seriously? Have you actually seen Votto hit? In four seasons as a full time hitter, his OPS has been .874, .981, 1.024 and .947. He would easily be the best hitter this organization has seen since ARod's departure over a decade ago. Legit MVP bats are the rarest commodity in baseball.
As far as trading Felix for him - it would have to be a three way since the only reason the Reds will trade him is because they know they can't afford his FA. They can't afford Felix. Felix to the Yankees, the Yankees prospects (Montero +++) to the Reds and Votto to Seattle might work, I guess.