1
Jack Wilson and Brendan Ryan roughly cancel each other out, anyway, it seems. Wilson's not on the list even though we extended him of our own free will.
On a 30,000-foot view, you try two NL-central SS's, and one crashes and the other's fairly useful ... those two dice rolls, in isolation, are two rolls that any GM (including Bavasi, Woodward, etc) might have taken.
Objectively speaking, I personally would grade [Wilson + Ryan together] as mediocre to dubious.