1
Not anti-Reynolds
He's one of the few who bashes enough to make up for the Ks (Howard, Bruce, Branyan, etc.). But if you like that kind of thing, I don't know why you wouldn't just plug Alex Liddi in there for absolutely no cost whatsover (salary or trade chips) and see if he can't do the same. And he's got a better shot of sticking around at 3b.
I like the Iwakuma-Jaso-[Seth Smith?]-Kawasaki low-risk, medium/high-reward approach for this team. Go for the super-elite or build from within. Expensive mid-grade Figgins, Branyan, Reynolds types don't really make sense at this stage.