Add new comment

There is no reasonable lineup given the current roster.  Wedge "wants" a classic lineup, and simply doesn't have the tools to match.  So, he's going to compromise six ways from Sunday and likely end up with an opening day lineup generally dispised by the masses, (but which might just be perfect in terms of "quick" identification of which bodies need to be dumped:
3B - Figgins - last hurrah - put up or shut up - no other OBP/Steal guy on the roster.
2B - Ackley - best projected hitter needs plenty of PAs.  Likely destined for #3 slot in the near future.  He's better suited to bat third than Ichiro is already, but this whole lineup is full of compromise.
RF - Ichiro - he might start here, but I doubt he'll stay here.
CA - Olivo - horror upon horror - but he led the club in HRs and he isn't a lefty.  Of course, this likely could place the three worst hitters on the ROSTER all at the top of the lineup in the ill-conceived attempt to match specific skills with "designated" top of the order "job descriptions".
1B - Smoak -- Star prospect isn't going to hit lower.
LF - Carp -- And we end up hitting the best hitter (by OPS) from 2011 6th in the lineup. 
DH - Montero/et al? -- while the great debate on whether Montero and Olivo will play in the same lineup routinely continues, you can either bench your 2011 team leader in HRs or your top prospect --- so you can plug in who, exactly -- Trayvon?  Liddi?  Seager perhaps?
CF - Guti -- his comeback will start with minimal pressure.  Accept his golden glove then see what happens with the bat.
SS - Ryan -- might swap with Guti - but Ryan has already hit 9th regularly.
This is basically what you get if you start with Figgy leading off and Ichiro hitting third.  Once you pencil in Ackley/Ichiro for 2/3, you end up with planning on three straight lefties, (Carp led the team in cleanup appearances, despite playing only 1/2 the season), or you shove Smoak where Wedge said he didn't like him, or you give the job to your entitled veteran who led the team in HRs.
This is why I keep saying, I'll believe these Ichiro/Figgy rumors are true once the season starts.  It could happen.  The only upside is that you allow Figgy, Ichi and Oli to fail quickly, while allowing your prospects to work with less pressure for awhile.
"Long" term? 
RF - Ichiro -- (assuming his bat returns enough to generate a .330 OBP).
CF - Guti - (assuming Figgy implodes and Guti returns)
2B - Ackley - (where he should be hitting from day one)
LF - Carp -- (where he should be hitting from day one)
1B - Smoak - (where he should be hitting from day one)
CA - Olivo/Montero - (relative PT will likely move throughout season)
3B - Seager - (after Figgy implodes)
DH - (you're the next contestant on Seattle's Got Talent!)
SS - Ryan
Realistically, the political heat of moving Ichiro *way* down in the order is going to prevent this from happening unless Ichiro truly stinks from day one.  Since it is far more likely that Figgy will stink from day one, and the club doesn't have anything resembling a 'true' leadoff hitter - Ichiro's SB prowess will return him to leading off in short order.
Wedge's love for aggression (and the inate weakness in total HRs on the roster), likely prevents Olivo from slipping lower than 6th in the lineup, unless he implodes. 
DH will be a revolving door - (last year 10 guys played DH - and Cust was #1 with 63 games with Carp #2 at only 19).   Pena was third at 17.  Of course, upon reading the name "Pena", my first question was "Who the heck was Pena?  I don't remember any Pena"  It was Wily Mo, just fyi.  You could win the America's Cup with the breeze from the revolving door that DH will likely be in 2012.