Add new comment

Catricala and Seager were both taken in the 2009 draft as college juniors.
Seager is a year older, but they were in the same year in school.  In other words, Seager was a college freshman at 19, but Cat was a college freshman at 18.
Seager played in a major conference (ACC -- UNC) while Cat was in a mid-major (WAC -- Hawaii).
Seager, therefore, got a more-aggressive placement at Clinton (low A) after signing; Cat got a less-aggressive placement at Pulaski (rookie).
But otherwise:
Catricala has 1446 professional plate appearances
Seager has 1423
Cat cumulative: .322/.397/.536
Seager cumulative: .318/.389/.461 (minors + MLB)
***
In other words, it is only slightly less reasonable to expect Catricala to be an MLB contributor at this stage than Seager.  Main differences are the one year of chronological age (though not college-pro playing duration); 117 PAs of AAA and 201 PAs of major leagues.
I expect they'll have Vinnie go through the paces at AAA (especially since they have other guys -- Guillen, L-Rod -- that they can "plug and play"), but I also expect him to be part of the 2012 offensive totals by the end of the year (moreso if Guillen and Figgins struggle with health or hitting or both).
Awesome to have both (and I'm not anti-Liddi, either, though I think he has a narrower window, and Vinnie seems to have -- appropriately in my mind -- eclipsed him at the moment).