Add new comment

There is more a reason to having a 2nd backup catcher backup  catcher beyond avoiding a couple embarassing at bats by the pitcher.  It allows you to replace the catcher in any situation.  You don't need to wait for someone to come up lame. 
Miguel Olivo's career OPS vs. Right Handed Pitching is .661.
John Jaso's career OPS vs. Left Handed Pitching is .605.
If you get to the late game and the opposing manager brings in a situational guy to face our (non-Montero) catcher in the 8th inning of a tie game with runners on, wouldn't it be nice if Wedge were able to pinch hit for Olivo with a previously benched Michael Saunders or Mike Carp, or if he were able to pinch hit for Jaso with Vinnie Catricala or Casper Wells?
Or what if it's the 7th inning, any one of our catchers get a base hit;  wouldn't it be nice to get a pinch runner out there that a) has a better chance to score and b) saves the catchers legs for the last 2 or 3 innings, then shuffle the defense around on the other half of the inning.
Not saying it would gauranteed to be the right move, but I DO see advantages to carrying a 3rd (offensively capable) catcher.