1
Stone notes that Vinnie is not on the 40-man, and speculates that adding Cat to the MLB roster and then sending him back down when they need Millwood as the #5 starter (which is what I thought they'd do), would needlessly use up an option year.
No issue there with Liddi, who is already on the 40-man, so they'll use up an option year for him anyway (unless he sticks in the majors all year -- unlikely).
But Liddi had a great camp, too, so I can't fault them either way. I like them both, but I think Vinnie has a much greater chance of long-term MLB success.
This will be a key year to see if Liddi can cut down on the killer K%.