1
I like the point that players are who they are and don't change from one level to another. Will Myers in AAA on June 10 is the same player as Will Myers in MLB on June 11.
Some players are more able to adapt to new situations, which a player will encounter in any transition. But like Dr. D has argued before, Michael Pineda was one of the best starters in MLB before he even got there. Mike Trout had the ability to be an MVP-caliber major leaguer when he was in AAA. And this is what Saberdogs lose sight of.
It seems James thinks that Myers is an upper-echelon talent regardless of where he plays.
Couldn't help but wonder from his tone, though, if his history as a Royals fan had any bearing on his opinion. ;-)