Add new comment

While writing the above comment on Saunders and Felipe Alou, it occurred to me how much Michael Morse's skills are like Cepeda's, and Montero's are like McCovey's. As you probably know, Cepeda came up in 1958 and hit well and played 1B for the Giants. The following year, McCovey came up and promptly set the baseball world on fire a la Mike Trout (I was at his first game where he hit a triple off of Robin Roberts that went off the right field wall and ended up in deep left). But he was NOT a good fielder, except as a 1B, where his size, soft hands, and knee-to-knee agility played pretty well. So Cepeda moved to the outfield, where his play was a major argument for the designated hitter - in fact Alou originally came up as a defensive replacement for late innings until he proved that he, too, could hit. Cepeda was not fast, but held on to what he got to. His routes were like Morse's. When he was traded to StL. to play 1B, I suspect he danced for joy.
Meanwhile, although McCovey could hit the ball harder than anyone I've ever seen (and I saw Aaron and Mays repeatedly and up close), he looked like a cross between an ostrich and a rhino while running. I saw him get thrown behind after rounding first during his first couple of years (once by Clemente) until he slowed on turning. At speed, he was not as slow as Montero, but he could not change direction or hit the bags smoothly when rounding them. But boy, did the ball and bat make a sound when he connected!