Forgotten Stars: Cecil Cooper (1982 Brewers)
Holy bananas, these guys were loaded with hitting!

Just take a look at that swing, just after contact. Fred McGriff instructional videos can't teach you to have better "back leg special" form than that. Note the back leg is taking all of the weight in the swing, the hips stay closed until after the bat clears the zone and are just now exploding out, his eyes are looking right out along the top of his bat, the energy has a distinctly upward trajectory (he's leaning waaaay back on follow-through - without a giant uppercut, he is still giving the ball lift). This is the model for how you produce pulled fly balls when you get your pitch and still hit for a high average.

This is Cecil Cooper.

File 1982 ALCS Gm5: Cecil Cooper raps clutch two-out hit

Look at him leeeeeaning into the pitch. He was fooled a bit on speed, so his back leg swing isn't there - you can see why he was able to hit for a high average. When he is just trying to put a tough pitch in play, he just flattens the swing plane and slows himself down.

Fun to watch.

Before I go much further with Cooper, take a look at these hilarious hitter WAR totals and the pedigree of the names involved...

  1. Robin Yount (10.5) - WOWZERS...his best season, combined offense and defense in 1982 (we'll call him Nomar Garciaparra plus glove)
  2. Paul Molitor (6.2) - With 42 steals, his real WAR was probably a bit higher when accounting for bases gained on other batted balls (John Olerud with speed playing average 3B rather than GG 1B)
  3. Cecil Cooper (5.6) - The metrics say he was a rather poor defensive first baseman, making his gold gloves seem dubious, and he carries a line not dissimilar to Boomstick
  4. Gorman Thomas (4.9) - Cooper is pretty well known to people who were closely following baseball in the 1980s, so I almost shifted my focus to Thomas, hit like Jay Buhner
  5. Ben Oglivie (3.4) - Mike Cameron level hitter but lacking the GG defense)
  6. Ted Simmons (3.3) - at the tail end of his productive prime, hitting roughly like Matt Wieters before he got hurt and with + defense behind the plate
  7. Jim Gantner (2.6) - high average slap hitter and well above average defensive second baseman, somewhat Luis Castillo-like
  8. Don Money (2.1) - a good hitter at the tail end of his career, similar to Cooper, lost time due to injury and was replaced by Roy Howell, who was...not so good - not far from Lyle Overbay offensively

So...the only 'hole' in their line-up was right fielder Charlie Moore (1 WAR, mostly defense).

How the farbot did this team not win 120 games?  Ah...right...their pitching was HORRENDOUS outside of Caldwell/Vukovich/Fingers.

They were also pretty bad defensively other than Yount, Gantner, Simmons and Moore.

But still, I'm trying to picture this club as, essentially Fast Olerud/Luis Castillo/Nomar/Boomstick/Buhner/Wieters/Cameron/Overbay/glovey right fielder.

WOW

Team OPS+ 121...LOL Yep - that's better than the 1997 Mariners.

And the guy I'm profiling was that team's clean-up hitter. :)

He doesn't make the HOF because his prime didn't begin until he was 29/30 and only lasted five years (and because he was a marginal defensive first baseman), but during that five-year stretch, he made four all-star appearances and was top five in MVP voting (5th every time) three times.

So what was he like as a teammate? When you ask around, you get three adjectives, "quiet, steady, humble". Perhaps because he was one of thirteen (!) kids in his family (the youngest of that huge brood), or perhaps because his father was big on humility and service, Cooper evidently liked to hide in the background. The media didn't pay him the attention he probably deserved, since his prime years were surrounded by...well...look at that list up there! But he probably preferred it that way. The guy, it should also be noted, got "edgared"...he was held back in the minor leagues for a LONG time despite showing plenty of ability, mostly because his defensive reputation was poor.

Even so, for a few years there, he was a franchise player.

Comments

1

Makes you wonder what baseball in Seattle would have been like if the Pilots had stuck around. Not that we suffered long in their absence, unlike with the whole NBA ridiculousness.

You can always wish to have had a longer peak, but it's hard to complain about a five year run like that one. Wow!

2

Named for Harvey Kuehn, their manager.  He was a heck of a player in his own right:  RoY in '53; led the league in hits 4 times, BA once and 2B's 3 times. 8-time AS.  Involved in one of the coolest trades in MLB history.  He led the league in hitting in '59 (.353), and in the off season, the ITigers traded him to Cleveland, straight up, for Rocky Colaveto, who had just led the league in HR's.  

Blockbuster deal.

Harvy's Brewers in '82-'83 could rip the ball. All of them, but Cooper was hardly anonymous. He was good.  For a long time he was good.

That team was a ball.  Molitor and Yount playing side-by-side, already on their way to the Hall.

Fun times.  Thanks Matt.

3

Ditto what Moe said. I liked Cecil Cooper a lot, precisely because of the demeanor Matt pointed out in the article. And he could flat out hit.

Good one, Matt.

4

Funny story in The White Rat, where Herzog the new Cardinal GM decides to clean house, air out the musty entitled St. Louis basement.  He calls the Milwaukee GM and doesn't even say hello.  "Hey, how would you like to win the National League pennant next year?"  Reply, dryly, "I'd like that just fine."

Throws Simmons, Vuckovich (a Cy Young winner who played the cleanup hitter in Major League, I think) and Rollie Fingers to them for scraps.  I'm not entirely certain Dave Cameron would have reviewed the trade positively, but the Cardinals won the World Series a year or two later.  The 80's version of the Wil Myers trade.

The Brew wound up with an Arena Baseball 10-deep lineup that was a portent of DiPoto Mariner lineups to come...

Add comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><p><br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

shout_filter

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.