http://paullebowitz.com/blog has an interesting rundown on Tanaka that's worth a look. He concludes it's Yankees, Cubs and Mariners, but his reasoning is interesting.
.
The Right Yujin, Dept.
As usual, the vibe from inside the industry makes 29 kinds of sense to SSI. This from MLB Trade Rumors:
- The Mariners will also be "a factor" for Tanaka, a baseball official tells Roger Rubin of the New York Daily News. “They have a following in Japan. They enjoyed what they had when Ichiro (Suzuki) was on the team. They want the chance for moves like getting [Robinson] Cano to pay off. And they envision [Felix] Hernandez paired with Tanaka at the top of the rotation," the official said.
You might be surprised at the tendency for large Fortune 500 organizations to develop personalities. That second sentence captures the M's front office perfectly, as a corporate organism that emphasizes comfort and enjoyment.
The Ichiro factor, and the Felix factor, those were the two main sources of baseball "enjoyment" for Lincoln and Co. since Gillick and Piniella left. Both players are/were "good actors," were a pleasure to have in class, players that the executives could embrace wholeheartedly and joyfully.
Both were, of course, ballplayers that the front office could market to rabid fan sectors. You can see for yourself how much gusto the Mariners have shown in catering to those fan sectors - turning all of Safeco Field into a giant yellow King's Court, wallowing in his "Felix Dance," and so on.
You and I think in terms of Tanaka's xFIP compared to Kuroda's, and Iwakuma's, but the Mariners think in terms of ability to connect with Pacific Rim fans. Iwakuma is good, but Tanaka has star power; he is likely the Mariners' last chance, for a while, to replicate the Ichiro Experience. The M's have a King's Court for Felix starts ... Tanaka's day-of-game promotions could rival those.
You don't care that much about the King's Court, you're thinking. You should be thinking, "How much does HOWARD LINCOLN care about the King's Court?"
There are other things to do at Safeco besides just watch a baseball game. I read it on the 'net.
.
How Much?
Tomorrow's news today at SSI. :- )
Other sites are speculating, breathlessly, that Tanaka's contract could approach $100M.
That would be correct, with one small tweak, that being if you replaced the "1" with a "2." Well ... closer to $200M than to $100M, by the time you include the posting fee.*
*$131M contract + $20M = closer to $200M than $100M. Could be more.
.............
Tanaka, as an asset, is one notch down from Felix and Verlander, since he hasn't yet proven it here. CC Sabathia got $160M for 8 years, quite a while ago, and then Felix and Verlander gave serious home town discounts to clock in at $175-180M. Tanaka's easily a $20M/year pitcher, maybe more, and at age 25 he's looking at 7-8 years.
Lots of serious analysts ::coughtonyblenginocough:: are complaining that no matter how good the free agent is, you're still being stupid, because the free agent is over 30 and you're buying his decline. Well, kiddies, here is a free agent who is 25. That, and the fact that 10 teams will be SERIOUSLY bidding, will helium the contract into next week.
..............
Should the M's pay?
Nobody is writing about where the industry's revenues are going. For a long time, the Manny Ramirez and ARod contracts sailed high because the revenues and salaries were going up by 10% (or more) a year. As Bill James put it, in that era you felt like WHATEVER you paid a Manny Ramirez, it would work out fine.
Now, then, we've gone through a short spell of relatively flat contracts, and our calibration is off.
But we're on the crest of another huge inflationary period. Today's prices will seem cheap in three years. Precisely because of that factor, this (and next) winter is the time for the Mariners to make their big purchases.
On Manny Ramirez, Miguel Cabrera, Felix Hernandez, etc., the question wasn't a million here or a million there. The question was whether he was your player, or somebody else's.
............
How about the Kenta Maeda factor? ... well ...
NEXT
.
Comments
A minor quibble, but even with the spending this off-season, I see it as the verge of a new period of rising revenues and rising contracts as a result - people are predicting $300M for Kershaw... I don't think we've crested yet.
Sorry.
It is interesting that Ichiro and Darvish act like rock stars and it makes them the hotter commodity than the every day dude. Here we have Iwakuma. He makes life decisions based on the wellbeing of his wife and kids. He doesn't pose nude in magazines, he doesn't wear zebra stretchy pants to batting practice, His baseballs are not kept in a humidor. He has not written the unreadable book. You might not notice him at all if he wasn't a contender for best pitcher in the world. I guess that I don't quite see the Star magazine stuff as value added for my Cy Young candidate, but then again I'm not into marketing.
Tanaka's marketability, guys? What say you? Would Tanaka starts in Safeco draw a large TV following in Japan, as compared to (say) Iwakuma's?
Ya that's what I meant. :- ) Thanks Bat.
Tanaka is a MUCH bigger star in Japan than Iwakuma. Nobody is going to have Ichiro's popularity, but Tanaka is popular in a different way. Hes likable. Good question as to who is more popular between Darvish and Tanaka.
Interesting comment from Casey McGehee, marvelling at Tanaka's fork.
It reminds you of a comment from an MLB hitter - I forget who - who had played in Japan. He said that Sasaki, in his prime, was absolutely the only pitcher he ever saw where he felt like "okay, how many pitches is this going to take." Based on the hot, located fastball and untouchable fork.
That's intriguing, when you bear in mind Tanaka's 26-0 season and three-year run of .900* winning percentages. Makes you wonder whether Tanaka could be a phenomenon.
.......
Also at MLBTR, it looks like the Rangers and Phillies are pretty much out. FWIW.
Apparently after the Rakuten Golden Eagles President let slip that Tanaka planned to help renovate the local stadium. MLB is insisting that nothing more than the $20M posting fee can go to the NPB club either directly or indirectly. I wonder if MLB would have the stones to protest if, after Tanaka signed with the Ms, Nintendo donated a sum to the Sendai recovery with part of the money to go to stadium renovation and upgrade. Nintendo does a LOT of business with Rakuten and in Sendai, so how could MLB object? Interesting development!
EDIT TO ADD: Nintendo has already been among the most generous contributors to relief for the entire Tohoku earthquake/tsunami impact zone, donating more than almost any other business concern. My comment is intended to reflect an attitude of questioning how MLB can hold the line preventing individuals, clubs, or ownership from donating to an area which has great needs, among which are the need to renovate and upgrade the local sports facilities. If Tanaka wishes to donate to this, I think it is his business. If the Yankees or Cubs or Dodgers or Angels wish to make such a donation, even though their ownership is in shipping, investment, investment, and billboards, respectively, while Nintendo is in a business, gaming, which was heavily concentrated in the affected region, any of them should be free to do so. While I can see the danger of allowing indirect payment to "top up" posting fees, the condition of the region the Rakuten Golden Eagles represents should be considered, as well. In my opinion, MLB should allow donations to charities and rebuilding efforts as long as they don't directly go to Rakuten or the Golden Eagles club. If the stadium is publically owned (it is owned by the Miyagi prefecture) donations for its renovation should be entirely allowed.
Tier 1 - Superstars: Ichiro, Darvish, Nomo
They have the talent. They might have the visual appeal (really, Darvish is the only one who's considered in the Statue of David sort of way). And they do what they like.
Ken Griffey, Jr. Derek Jeter. David Ortiz. That sorta dude.
However, Darvish is pretty down to earth on Twitter...
Tier 2 - Almost Superstars: Tanaka, Sasaki, Uehara
These guys are up there, but they're more accessible and are more widely media-friendly as well. Both appear on TV shows during the off season and have widespread appeal based more on personality and pure talent than the glam and looks of the Tier 1 dudes. Kinda like Felix Hernandez, Evan Longoria, Andrew McCutchen, etc.
Tier 3 - Stars: Kuroda, Iwakuma, Aoki, Iguchi
These guys are the types that are more from the more boonies teams of the NPB, like Hiroshima, Sendai, Fukuoka, second Tokyo or Kansai team, etc. They're generally well respected and are immensely talented, but more or less are just guys that fans would know. Think along the lines of Edgar Martinez, Kyle Seager, any Oakland A's player, etc.
Tanaka will guarantee that the M's will be broadcast when Tanaka starts. Right now, it's hit or miss with Iwakuma. If Ichiro & Kuroda starts or Davish starts, the M's game would probably be bumped.
Tanaka's basically been asked as a gentleman's agreement to sort of pay towards a trust or something to help Tohoku in exchange for his posting release to the MLB. But that said, Nintendo would probably be discreet enough to do any kickbacks if those were part of the cards that would help the M's get Tanaka.
Thanks, Ice. This gives me a great feel for the situation. Me? I never thought the superstar type ego played well in the PNW. The NFL and the Seahawks seem to be the exception? Perhaps it's simply the personalities surrounding the M's. Rizzs, Blow, Lincoln, etc. They don't seem to go for the flashy types. It makes 'em uncomfortable. All that to say: by your analysis, Tanaka seems right up their alley.
The commish has a lot of power he can yield if he suspects funny business and wants to do something about it.