Isn't that what the first guy in used to say at LL when they got like 500 comments to a Jeff Sullivan thread ...
Re-timestamp to put the bottom of the list first, correct?
Saving my own "Tomorrow's News Today" sofa time for Thursday morning Gordon .... thanks mucho!
Comments
thanks for the time and effort.
's a great point about people 'subconsciously' pairing him with Vlad -- whereas we're likely to never again see Vlad Guerrero. That is a conversation-ender.
A lot of times when I see prelim Top 100's, it has three M's hitter on it ... DJ, Alex Jackson (solidly), and ... Gabe Guerrero (fringe). For example, the M's own site has Guerrero 3rd in the system, behind only those two.
Any comment on that? You've got "7" on the heat meter, acknowledging the excitement, but .... does it have any merit to rank him ahead of Austin Wilson, Kivlehan, Marte, Hultzen, etc? Can't imagine drafting Guerrero (today) ahead of the likes of those guys.
If you had to argue in a court of law that Guerrero is the M's #3 protectee in an expansion draft (per the M's-site list) how would you argue it?
As DJ could now, I take it you're saying.
Very provocative, that any of these 4 players could emerge like that imminently. That's a generic comment about big years for minor leaguers or an admiration of their special talent?
Gracias,
Jeff
These two threads are an analogue for "Hey Bill" at BJOL, except it's micro-targeted to the M's minors.
Youse guys should exploit the opportunity. .... In fact maybe that's a feature we should nest on the front page?
Hey Gordon for the minors, Hey Mojo for political/legal issues, Hey Matt for math-intensive saber, Hey Doc for requests to take the site down ... I'm not entirely kidding on some of those.
Thanks Doc. :) I keep wishing for more time in my schedule to talk baseball, but for a little bit longer I'm trapped away from the site for large swaths of the day. Shouldn't be much longer, I hope.
And the case for Gabe Guerrero goes like this: He was just 20 in the Cal League, was chosen to play in the Futures Game (alongside Peterson) and was chosen as a mid-season All-Star OVER DJ. He's about Saunders-sized and can swipe 20+ bags a year if he wants to. That rawness in his approach makes people dream about his upside.
I guess I've just seen too many "Electric Bat" Pimentels in my time as an Ms fan who can't adjust to better pitching. Now, Gabe DID get better from his first stint in full season in the MWL last year (where he OPSed .660 in a pitcher's league but average park). He OPSed .770 on the road in the Cal League, which is a nice improvement. I'm not saying he doesn't have interesting tools, because he absolutely does. He can hit the ball hard, and he can put balls sharply in play that were not in the zone, like his uncle, but I'm way leery.
It's like Marte. Ketel has a great baseball attitude, is a total gamer, can make some special plays in the field (when he's not messing up other plays), hits .300, is a flat baby out there compared to his competition... but it just feels to me like cheering for David Eckstein. There is absolutely nothing wrong with having one of those in your system, but I wouldn't consider him your most valuable prospect if you have any kind of system.
Gabby is a good prospect, has lots of upside and time to grow into it - but he's not the third best prospect in our system for me.
If he's valued by other teams as the third best player in our system and fairly equivalent to Peterson, then by all means let them give us a vital piece for Guerrero at that price. I'm all ears.
Part of it is situational:
- O'Neill and Wilson should start off in the Cal League next year, with Wilson on the Peterson/ Kivlehan half-season promotion plan. We're switching parks, thankfully, but Bakersfield is still decently offensive-minded (though not to the ridiculous degree that High Desert was, or Lancaster is) so both guys should look good there hitting balls into the setting sun.
- Choi is repeating AAA (sort of, since he didn't have a full year there) and without the suspension breaking up his year I expect him to do well.
- Austin Jackson should get into full-season ball and have a chance to really impress.
- Kivlehan and Peterson should both be healthy and ready for AAA.
- And we still have room for surprises (like Pizzano, Marte, Guerrero, Smith, Marlette... whoever).
I expect the hitters in the system to do well next year. Not so sold on our starting pitching, but there are some guys who could still really impress in the low minors, and Diaz will be ready to start his climb up to the upper minors to join Sanchez, Landazuri and co (assuming they're still here).
This was a weird year with injuries for several of our top prospects (Wilson, O'Neill, Landazuri, even DJ a bit among others). Nothing especially serious or career-threatening, which is good. Just some missed time masking a bit of the talent in the system. I expect those clouds to clear next year.
When Austin Wilson is pulling a Kris Bryant-like explosion next year in the Cal League, that value will climb. Here's hoping, anyway. ;-) He's got the talent for it. If he has the year he SHOULD have, he's another headliner. O'Neill can absolutely be a top-100 player after next season, especially with his power potential - which can be Springer-esque.
Marlette has me really curious - if he can handle a full-time catching gig, his performance could be pretty special. Just a lot of guys who could take off - and at least a couple of them should. I'm feeling pretty strong about our young hitters.
Top Ms hitters, 2008: Clement, Triunfel, Balentien, Saunders, Tui... and nobody
Top Ms hitters, 2014: Jackson, Peterson, Kivlehan, Wilson, O'Neill, Marte, Guerrero, Marlette, Morgan and more
Even if Marte and Guerrero turn out to be Triunfel and Balentien, I like rest to be better than Clement, Tui and Saunders for sure.
It's nice not to have to have EVERY decent prospect hit his upside in order to tread water. Rather than having to pray for luck, we just have to NOT get unlucky - normal prospect success rates will bring us a couple of good major leaguers without any special thumb on the scale. If we can add a hitter and a pitcher every year from the farm, the Mariners can be a self-sustaining contender even with our weirdly-constricted budget.
Let's hope that's how it works out, anyway.
~G