In terms of back-to-back Game Scores comparable to that Scherzer eruption. Named twenty guys since WWII, or something.
Like you say, getting comped to Max Scherzer would be pretty cool, especially if you were Brandon Morrow ... you want to name one forseeably disastrous pick the M's have made early, that's my choice. D-O-V threw quite a hissy fit at the time. There's a long series of POTD's on the 2006 amateur SP's somewhere in the internet archives.
In the 2006 draft, we begged for Lincecum, if not him then Scherzer or Kershaw, over the kid with the 97 MPH fastball and the faint, tentative "ki" in his makeup. Lincecum, Scherzer and Kershaw all went bing-bing-bing right after Morrow at #5.
The M's took Morrow and gloated. "We've been watching him closely since high school."