1
http://www.minorleaguesplits.com/cgi-bin/pl.cgi?pl=455077
Looking at that Carp actually rates out as an above-average defensive 1B in the minors. I wonder if this is just something the scouts are getting wrong? I'm looking for evidence that Carp is a poor fielder and I just can't find it. Even his short time in the majors he rated as a +5 run fielder.
Btw Everidge is an awful defensive 1B. Hes a DH really. A platoon DH at the MLB level at best. Hes the AAA DH this year hopefully, and hopefully they waive him so he doesn't cost a 40-man roster spot.