Add new comment

I have a copy of it on my computer, they have him at .292 in '07, .285 in '08, and he hit more line drives in '09, the xBABiP calculator doesn't work the same as the tables, I guess it's a bit more limited, I put in his exact '08 stats and it spits out .310.  Speed, if anything, is the one thing that can be measured far more easily by scouts than by stats, so the speed score doesn't mean much when people keep saying he's quick for a first baseman.  That said, the stolen base rate could just be that he sucks at reading pitchers, the runs scored stat depends extensively on the other players on his team, but Kotchman was still at 30% in '07 and 29% in '08, he's being dragged down by a 20% rate from '09 when he batted 6th, 7th, and 8th most of the time and needed to be batted in by either the eigth batter on the Braves (.692 OPS from that spot last season) or the pitcher, and if he was lucky, the leadoff man.  As far as runs scored, he would have got 87 in '07 at the rate he was going and 78 in '08, he was once again held back by his position in the lineup in '09, dragging down his career average.
 
Ibanez was better at Safeco 3 out of 5 years, Ichiro better 5 out 8(with one draw), and Griffey was certainly better at Safeco last year.  The study I'm using is Home Run Park Factor—A New Approach , that says it's easier to hit a home run at right field in Safeco than almost any other ballpark (not accounting for wind that would help, or humidity that would hurt).
 
I wrote this to you on the other Kotchman article, maybe you missed it there, if you look at Baseball-Reference, Kotchman's a .900 OPS hitter to left OR right field, and .600 to Center.  Baseball-Reference I assume is a little more liberal with what counts as Center Field, maybe, but still, my point about being limited by his park stands, it's hard to hit a high OPS when what power you have ends up as deep flyballs, he does pull nearly twice as often as he pushes.  Safeco's right field is not supposed to aid his line drives or groundballs, it's supposed to turn his career HR/FB% to right from 25% to 30 or maybe 35%.
 
And the Productive out bit was a toss in, I'm well aware that those aren't necessarilly that helpful, however, his baserunner scored rate is still well above average despite below (his own) average power when runners are in scoring position.  So I think his productive outs score runners more often than most players, that and I think he's got a very manageable ego that lets him aim primarily not to strike out (his career K rate is 8% with runners in scoring position, 9% when they aren't) or hit for much power when he has a chance to score a runner.