1
I just can't agree with the premise of the article Doc. Mike Scoscia says he can't catch, so obviously he can't catch... Thats not enough IMO.
Lets break down Napoli's defense part by part and make a fair assesment of how much docks off his value.
We've covered the arm and PBs and Bref already accounts for both. Then I guess its just game-calling. Is Napoli so bad that it takes a 4.2 WAR star catcher down to replacement level?