Add new comment

I, too, disagree with the idea of being "more aggressive" in order to bust out of a slump.  It often means just swinging at pitches that you have LESS chance of finding a hole with.  The same aggressive solution does not fix each and every slump.
If a batter gets "their" pitch 3 times a night would be about normal, I suppose. He gets the pitch he wants (is looking for)  in the zone he likes.
If being more aggressive is hacking away, regardless, well you probably turn into a Yuni Betancourt.  If being more aggressive is going after the first fastball you see, well you probably will handle some.  If being more aggressive is saying "I'm driving the first _______ that I see on the __________ part of the plate," well then you've becoming a discerning hitter, but still agressive.
It's hard to say that a Ted Williams or Barry Bonds or Adam Dunn (well, not the '11 variety) was not an aggressive hitter.  Yet they walked a ton.  Williams had a career .482 OBP, for goodness sake!  He WALKED ..138!  He took a ton of pitches but was aggressive when he got the one he wanted.
So from my standpoint, if Wedge's intent is to get more batters to swing more harder (sic) more often, well.......it ain't helping and it probably won't.
You probably don't make a batter better by asking him to be something he isn't.  Some great putters bang the ball into the back of the cup (Tom Watson), some die the ball into the hole (Ben Crenshaw).  but asking Watson to be Crenshaw probably doesn't fix a slump.
Batters get out of slumps by recognizing pitches they can handle (Saunders seems to have no such recognition gene) and then squaring tghe bat on the ball.  Teach that, and you end slumps.
BTW, I posted a couple of days ago (and it seems lost in the electronic ether) that Peguerro is in historically uncharted waters.  True 2.5 Option guys can survive if their OBP approaches .300.  Dave Kingman, Rob Deer, Pete Incaviglia and even '09 Miguel Olivio are guys in this template.  I'm talking about guys that are 20+ homer, 30K's/100AB types.  This is doable and valuable player, especially if you get to 30+ taters.
But if you set the search to guys who have .250 OBP's, or worse (Peg's is currently .250), then you find ZERO players ever who hit 20+ homers, K'ed 30/100AB's and had a max. .250 OBP.  Nobody.  The template doesn't exist.
Essentially that says that at 30K's/100 AB's and not enough HIT or EYE to get to OPB of .250 that no manager in history will play a power hitter full time.
If you drop the homer requirement to 10 homers you find Sammy Sosa in '91 (330+ PA's).  If you drop it to 5 homers, you find a bunch of utility IF types.
A fulltime Peguerro (at his current production) doesn't exist, historically, in baseball.  Look it up.
Mostly is says that Peguerro is out of his league.
A more aggressive Peguerro would be out of his league even a level down.
moe