Reality Check: Felix Hernandez, $31 at HQ, or $30 at SSI

Forecaster now shipping.  As you know, we live to serve.  You, not Ron, that is.

Not that HQ is infallible, of course.  For Ron's 25th Anniversary Edition, he wrote an op-ed saying, in effect, "Everybody else's guess is now as good as mine."  Which is also where James, Dr. D and everybody else in the over-50 league is these days.

But HQ is a neutral source.  They're not too close to the situation to see the warts on a pitcher.  They're also not so DC-Current-Conditioned by "No Cheering In The Press Box" that they have to avoid saying somebody's good, if he is...

Text in italics is my characterization of Shandler's position on Mariner players, not his actual statements on them.  This is done both to steer clear of copyright issues, and to give a bit of color (muave?  ochre?) to the reviews ... hey, we used to make a fair livin' with these kinda scan-and-exec-sums.  Cheap at half the price.

.

=== Felix Hernandez, $31 ===

THE BEARDED PROPHET:  Improvement from 2009 seemed impossible.  He improved.  ... don't like his innings, but unless they catch up with him ...$31.

Felix one of ten (10) hitters and pitchers worth $30+ in 5x5 roto, and the #1-1 pick in a sim-league draft.

Sim projection:  37 RAR, best in the game.

.

The Mainframe Sez:  Plenty of upside from here, if Felix will transition away from all the pitch-to-contact, knee-high fastballs and transition into fastballs up, fastballs off the plate and offspeed pitches with two strikes.

Felix is the best pitcher in baseball, him or Lee.  He can get considerably better.

.

HQ bids whatever it takes to get Felix - $30, $35, whatever.  Same here.  Felix has reached the point to where he is a legit 1-1 pick in an AL-only draft.

Not only is Felix great, but he's also 240, 250 innings.  The 21st-century Seaver/Clemens.  Hey, and as far as roto W's go, it's not like his offense could get worse...

Whale of a great place for a roto champ, or for Jack Zduriencik, to start his baseball team.

.

Trade Talk:  Interesting, and courageous, chatter that has been launched by the beat writers on the concept of dealing Felix for five of somebody's best-and-brightest.

As a general rule, Stars & Scrubs wisdom dictates that there really is no way to deal a Felix Hernandez and improve your team. 

You can only put 25 guys on the roster.  Who's the 5th guy in the package?  Somebody who is redundant with Michael Saunders.  Who's the 4th guy?  Somebody redundant with Josh Leuke and Dan Cortes.

It's intriguing, but the way the math works, Felix' "marginal production" is going to be worth more than five minor leaguers' "marginal production."   If everybody on your roster is worth 25 cents and Felix is worth $1.00, there's no way to take back enough 30-cent players to make it work.

Now, if you get five Justin Smoaks and Michael Pinedas, five guys at 75 cents who are also making rookie salaries, that's another subject...   does any team have 4-5 of those, besides us?  :- )

 

Comments

1
Taro's picture

Felix is about right at $30, although theres probably more downside then upside ERA-wise unless he increases his dominance. Would probably pass though in reality for a different star type with the money and fill the rotation with slightly undervalued/upside arms.
I definitely pass on Fister, Vargas, and Pauley. You hope to land a Fister/Vargas type with your $1-3 gambles.
Bedard you wait for the reports in ST. Velocity readings and stamina. Potential for a huge bargain, but much more likely to be a waste of roster money, so you want to keep a close eye.

2

I hear you, as to the downside with Felix.  I mean, scenario A, he earns $30; scenario B, he gets hurt or something, right? 
You hate to spend where there's a 70% chance of breaking even and a 30% chance of losing big money...
Just the same, if Felix is there in the middle of the first round, and it's your turn, it's not like you can pass him, right...

3

I definitely pass on Fister, Vargas, and Pauley. You hope to land a Fister/Vargas type with your $1-3 gambles.

You must not be talking about 5x5 or sim, since the IP themselves are worth $8, $10 bucks?
Or you think that Fister and Vargas are going to post 5.50's or something?

4
Taro's picture

It really depend on league type. Are you talking AL-only non-auction leagues? It would depend on scoring categories, points/roto, teams, positions, etc.
Would pass on Fister/Vargas/Pauley in almost any type of league though at those prices. Felix at $30 makes sense depending on league factors.
In general you don't want to pay for guys that hit close to their best case scenarios in the year prior (especially lower end talent). Its nearly impossible to make profit that way.

5

In a non-pro league (meaning one not based in Seattle!) a player of your caliber can expect to gold-pan a Fister caliber pitcher for free.

Add comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><p><br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

shout_filter

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.