Was It "EMBARRASSING" for Peyton Manning?
Legacy, dept.

.

Embarrassment, n.  A feeling of self-consciousness, guilt, or awkwardness.  The state of feeling foolish and/or confused in front of other people.

...

1.  I like Peyton Manning, and I believe that the sportswriter "champ vs chump" paradigm is --- > usually out of contact with reality.

...

2.  There is nothing embarrassing about losing, as such.  The San Francisco 49er's obviously have nothing to be embarrassed about.  In fact, they are not feeling embarrassed.  They are feeling like they want payback.

Neither is there anything inherently embarrassing about losing in a blowout.  If LeBron James beat me at 1-on-1, I wouldn't feel foolish.

...

3.  The Broncos' receivers, in the second half, started looking around for defenders as the ball was in the air, started blowing their routes, etc.  This was understandable.  It is also the definition of "having your will to win taken away."

Manning also lost focus in a manner comparable to that of his receivers.

When a team plays otherwise than with an implacable will to win -- a 49er-type snarling defiance in defeat -- it embarrasses itself.  This is why the Mariners generally, since Lou Piniella, have been an embarrassment.

Felix holds his head high, rising above the embarrassment.  He'll go into New York and shut the Yankees out, 1-0.  The Seattle Mariners as a team have not had this attitude.  The Chuck Armstrong legacy is that of financial strength and an embarrassing end product.

It embarrasses me to root for such a team.  

...

4.  The Broncos were sensational all year long, lighting people up, and then when it mattered the most, when they faced tough opposition, they backed down.  (They wound up completing 34 passes, but ... when was their initial first down?  When were their first points scored?)

During the year, they accepted the glory as the NFL's best offense -- the very State of the Art.  

They enjoyed being praised as the State of the Art, and did nothing to deflect it.  As we're typing, there's an NFL sound bite of them yelling at each other on the sideline, "We're the best ***** offense to ever play this game." They accepted the anointing as Historically Great, before the championship game.

Then, when the championship game occurred, they played otherwise.

Even more embarrassing, on The Day After, they are still protesting that they are a great team and that people should be praising them.  They're trying to salvage a legacy as the best offense ever.

.

Dr's Diagnosis

Yes, by any definition of the term, the 2014 Denver Broncos suffered one of the Super Bowl's greatest-ever embarrassments, maybe exceeded only by that of the Colts in Super Bowl III.  Not because they lost, but because they nodded, smiled, and waved to the world accepting the glory as All-Time Greats -- and then they had their will to win destroyed, in front of 110 million people.

That's not grounds for imprisonment, or banishment from the NFL, or eviction from the Hall of Fame.  What it is, is embarrassing.

.......

When the Seahawks beat down the 49er's in CLink early in 2014, it took San Francisco several weeks to overcome their confusion and embarrassment.  BUT!  Like Chuck Knox says, "When a MAN's butt hits the floor.  He Gets Back Up."

I'm not quick to blame a quarterback for a loss in a Big Game.  But in my opinion, Peyton Manning confirmed, in this game, that his makeup is different than that of Tom Brady or Joe Montana ... or, probably, Russell Wilson.

I don't care for Colin Kaepernick, but he's got the makeup you want.   HE is the one who is "classy in defeat," because his shoulders aren't slumped and his chest isn't collapsed.  My admiration for the 2013 San Francisco 49er's is vast.

When you accept a franchise QB like Peyton Manning, with his frontrunner, Older Brother, "bully" makeup, you take the good with the bad.  Sure, Peyton Manning has done a lot in the NFL.  His achievements did occur.  His 2013 season was a microcosm of his career -- a lot of flash and success, but without the heart of a champion -- and that's his legacy at SSI.

My $0.02,

Dr D

 

Blog: 

Comments

3

I always felt like Manning was enormously talented, but not emotionally strong. He and Eli both...there is an internet meme going around right now..."Manning Face" - the looks of total bewilderment and pathetic (in the dictionary definitional sense) sadness they give when they face "quicksand" as Falco put it in "The Replacements." If you are a great QB...you don't get "Manning Face"...you just don't. You get angry...you start knocking heads...you work harder...you demand more from yourself...you expect to come back stronger. You don't nearly cry on national TV because your team got its brain beat in by a real football team.

5
Auto5guy's picture

It wasn't just Manning.
I kept waiting for somebody... anybody, on the Broncos to lower their head for a helmet to helmet hit or to lay someone out with a late hit and unashamedly take the flag, just to make the statement. "You're not just going to push us around."
It never happened.
The receivers got shorter arms and the defense was weakly arm tackling by the end. At no point did a single guy man up, draw a line and make a stand.
It was sad... and sure as heck should have felt embarrassing.

6
bsr's picture

It's a great point, absolutely the Broncos should have stepped up and fought back -- but it's not their team's character. You can't fake it I don't think. E.g., Carolina Panthers tried to act tough against SF in the first half, but it just came off unfocused and paradoxically made them look weaker (and the refs weren't having it either). SF just smirked at all the nonsense, and ran them off the field. Compare to SF-Seattle, two teams that embody controlled, confident, and well-coached aggression. (Meanwhile Carolina too, like Denver, has a front-running QB who slumps and pouts when the going gets rough. The QB is critical to overall team attitude.)

7

Much weeping, wailing, and gnashing of teeth ... precisely about the problem of the Broncos being soft.  They're calling for a complete overhaul to deal with physical NFL teams.
Once again, SSI gave you tomorrow's news today :- )

8
bsr's picture

Gregg Easterbrook had some good analysis of the game (as always). He called the Broncos' punt on 4th and 11 down 29 "the single worst play in all of football history":
"Who cares if it was fourth-and-11? The Broncos absolutely had to score on that possession. As the punt team trotted in, Peyton Manning trotted off with his head hanging, not protesting the decision. There is no way on God's green Earth that Tom Brady, Drew Brees or Brett Favre would have trotted off passively in that situation. They would have gone to their coaches agitated, demanding a try. This play, not any of the interceptions -- trotting off without trying -- was Manning's worst down in any of his many postseason flameouts." http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/10398760/seattle-super-bowl-dominance-...
Really it did seem to me like the entire team (first and foremost coach and QB) realized toward the end of the 2nd quarter that the Hawks were so much better than them in every aspect of football, that it wasn't even worth trying to win anymore.

Add comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><p><br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

shout_filter

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.