Late Bloomers - What is the Prototype?
And no, don't say "Players Who Escaped Seattle." SSI is a no easy jokes zone.

 

Q.  Since studies don't exist, or you don't know about them, where do you start?

A.  A little snippet by James might help here ...

I have two points, and my only excuse for bringing them both up to you is that I think they are somewhat related. The first is that I believe a lot of fans think making successful, efficient moves as a general manager is some combination of sabermetric shrewdness and scouting acumen. I believe the merit of general manager decisions over time has at least as much to do with traits harder to define. Maybe good decision-making? Practicality? My second thought is that the kind of analysis that a fan does where he compiles all of a GM's trades and signings and rates how many were good and how many bad is really pointless.
Asked by: davidharris
Answered: 8/15/2012
When I started counting stolen bases allowed by catchers, people used to tell me it was pointless because it didn't include the pitchers.   When I proposed the Pythagorean method people told me it was pointless because it didn't measure a team's ability to win close games.  
 
Every measurement starts out with naive assumptions or crude assumptions, and gradually refines them.   You have to start somewhere.  

 

James has never been afraid to take a crude cut at an issue, provided that his crude cut involves facts and objectivity, rather than opinions and baloney.  You gotta start somewhere.

.

Q.  So where DO you start?

A.  How about with an objective list :- ) of 20, 30 hitters who were late bloomers.  Let's take guys who were less-than-average at age 27, roughly speaking.  That won't mean much with respect to Mike Carp, but it's a reductio ad absurdum.  If every late bloomer at age 30 is Adam Dunn or his ilk, we'll notice it that way.

I'll grab who I can think off, of the top of my head, out of the recent hitting leaderboards, and we'll just add the hitters off this list here.

What would be better, would be if I had a database from 1921 to 2012, could define OPS for ages 21-27 and then OPS plus something for ages 28+.  Why don't you do that.  While you do, I'll just list 20-30 guys and look at them.

Okay, my own guys ... 

Raul Ibanez, Josh Willingham, Jayson Werth, Nelson Cruz, Geronimo Berroa, Jose Bautista, David Ortiz, maybe Jason Varitek no forget him he's a catcher and maybe didn't bloom late, Matt StairsLuke Scott maybe ... the non-ballplayers.  Jeff Conine, Hal McRae languished on the bench of my Big Red Machine but maybe he was just frozen out like Edgar, Jose Guillen ... 

Huh.  Does anybody notice any RBI men in this list?

Okay, let's see what Bleacher Report has... Lefty O'Doul, a converted pitcher.  Gavvy Carvath, Kevin Millar that's a good one, Elston Howard no he was just frozen out and in the military, Scott Brosius nah he was never good for more than a year or two, then they have three or four guys we already named.  Oh!  Just remembered Carlos Guillen.  How could we forget.

.

Q.  Wait a second.  Maybe you're just not thinking of the leadoff guys who should be on here?

A.  Maybe, but I doubt it.  If a player can run and slap the ball on the ground, I bet you it doesn't take him until age 30 to learn how to do it.

Like Chone Figgins blossomed a bit late? ... no, he was an MVP candidate at 26, and at 25 his OPS+ hadn't been much different.   But!  Check me on this point.

.

Q.  What are the patterns?

A.  OK ...

Comments

1
TAD's picture

3-4 weeks ago I was reading on the blogosphere (sorry can't remember which blog) where a scout was giving some insight as to what they look for, and he indicated that a team will give a player more opportunities if he shows either power or speed. This is probably why you will see a higher number of 'older' power hitters breaking into the league at a later age, and also on the speed side an occasional Scott Podsednik.
For pitching it would be analagous to power pitchers or crafty left handers.

2

Lahair's the ugly-duckling equivalent of Jason Vargas or Jamie Moyer.  As it happens, we have a GM who doesn't look for pretty prospects....
And that's common to just about every guy we happened to think of:  certainly no speed, probably no eye-popping power, and no Youkilis level of walks...
Just the same, like we sez in the other thread, there's such a thing as a late bloomer, right?  

3
muddyfrogwater's picture

Certainly for success we're hoping two have a group of hitters who are outside of normal All Star caliber range but could certainly put forth their best seasons at age 26 to 28. Guys who have elevated themselves from league average to solid players. Maybe a player who hits well but has limitations. Hello Mike Carp, Or just simply a late bloomer. I could see keeping Vinnie stashed away until 25 or 26. If he burns his tires before hand then let him out of the chute.
Will the real Edgar Marineez please stand up.
The team is in desperate need of a break out from a mid-twenties player or two.
Why does Olivo have more AB's than Jaso? That's Ridiculous.

Add comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><p><br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

shout_filter

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.