Goin' ta War, 2
Pumpkins at midnight, Dept: the 30-day comps

.

Okay, Kevin Millwood is not actually Tim Hudson 2009 or Derek Lowe 2010.  You're not going to give him that contract.  But, for the past 30 days (and indeed for this entire season), there's been no functional difference there.  You could fit the past 30 days of Millwood's performances onto the back of a Hudson or Lowe baseball card and wouldn't notice anything awry.  To put it another way:  if the Mariners had given Hudson or Lowe a contract, and received from Hudson or Lowe what Millwood has given them, they'd have had no complaints.

So, LrKrBoi29, note carefully that SSI ain't calling Blake Beavan the 21st-century answer to Catfish Hunter.  We're saying -- and we're right -- that for the last 30 days, they've received an impersonation.

So off we go.  Here's why we threw down the comps we did.

.

=== Walter Johnson, SP1 ===

You can do this one as well as we, or James, could.  Pick your own name.  The 2012 Seattle Mariners go down the stretch with a 1988-Hershiser-class horse to carry them.

.

=== David Cone or Kevin Appier, SP2 ===

The last 30 days, six starts, Hisashi Iwakuma has fanned 8.8 men and walked 2.6, with an average HR rate.

He does it with a stinging little 90-93 fastball and a game-breaking offspeed pitch, the shuuto.  Also David Cone, the older version, fanned 8 men and walked 3-4 with a 90-93 fastball, and power slider.

Both SP's walked 3+ men per game not because of command, but because they didn't give in to hitters on 2-0.  Both men had 4-5 pitches.  Right now Hisashi Iwakuma indeed has been the 90-MPH version of David Cone.

Kevin Appier, once he was 30+ years old, pitched similarly.  ... if you're tapping your chin here and thinking that Mr. WBC has been the Big Secret to the M's run?  You're right.

He's still not popular.  The Mariners as an org still find his presence vaguely distasteful.  They need to get over that, real quick.  There's every chance that Iwakuma-san could spend two or three years as the 35-year-old David Cone.  Why deny yourself the benefits of your own dice roll?

.

=== Jamie Moyer, Jimmy Key SP3 ===

You guys can comp Vargas like you can Felix.  The last 30 days, he's racked up 1.2 WAR.  That's 7+ over the course of a season.

And Dr. D still is behind the curve on Vargas.  I think to some extent he's a Safeco illusion.  But the guy's got the stones of a burglar and like we sez, if his face looked like Tom Glavine's...

.

=== Brad Radke or Doug Fister '10, SP4 ===

Dr. D still is not buying long on Blake Beavan, either.  I'm not handing him 4/$45M if he's a free agent this winter.

But!  The last 30 days, since being reincarnated with a slider to defend himself with, his K's are 5.50 - right at the Shandler line - and his walks are

.

.

.

Wait for it 

.

.

.

.

.

.

0.52 men walked per 9 innings.

Are we sabermetricians or are we not?  So what do you do when a starting pitcher rips off an 11:1 command ratio and sustains it like this?

Catfish Hunter -- who of course lived off located fastballs, as Beavan does -- gave up some dingers, too.  In 1973, when the A's won the whole shebang, Catfish went 21-5 and led the American League in home runs allowed, 39 of them.  At least Beavan pitches in Safeco.  When Beavan is on this kind of roll, getting close to 6 K's per game (over the Shandler line) and walking 0+, you can speak of Catfish-type performances.  ... more feasibly you can compare Brad Radke, or the earlier version of Doug Fister, to Good Beavan

If you like saber CROSSED with tools scouting, then remember this:  few pitchers can walk 0.5 men per game without getting blasted.  It takes some serious chops to throw that many strikes and not get Vasquezed.

.

=== Hudson 2H, Lowe 2H, SP5 ===

Kevin Millwood for the season has 6.60 strikeouts, 2.99 walks, and a piddling 0.61 homers allowed.  The piddling HR's are why we think of Hudson and Lowe, though they keep their HR's down with sink, rather than with guile.

Millwood has delivered that kind of season.  And Jack Zduriencik does get a golfclap.

.

=== KRod, Closer ===

Hot fastball, devastating 12-6 power breaker.  Right?

.

=== Piazza, Cleanup Hitter ===

John Jaso, the last 30 days has .... wait for this too ... 16 walks and 9 strikeouts.  WHAT ARE YOU KIDDING ME!  His OBP is .455 and that's with buckets full of doubles and home runs.

Whoop.  Two more walks Sunday, no strikeouts.  18:9 EYE.  That's like Edgar in the low minors.

Jaso looks like a 1000 OPS hitter as he synchs with pitches in flight.  He is in a zone the likes of which the M's have rarely seen in the last ten years.  Here comes the pitch and Jaso falls into the ball as if in a hypnotic trance.  He simply will not swing at a ball, and he is ready to sock the ever-lovin' stuffing over any speed pitch that dares to venture within reach of his bat.

It's vertigo-inducing to think that maybe Jaso is going to finish the year with a 150 OPS+ ... that would be top-5, entire league ... but he might.  The man has 121 walks and 114 strikeouts, career.  And he's always had gap power (30 doubles, 12 homers is his normal career rate and his SLG is .500 for the year).

.

=== Rest of Lineup ===

Don't tell Dr. D that anybody else is helping; they're not.  They're hurting us less than they used to.  It's been the Jaso show, period.

Especially the guys we need to -- Ackley, Seager, Montero and Smoak -- have climbed up to "meh."  That's a long climb up from where they were.

So there y'have it.  Zduriencik got Iwakuma and Beavan in there, he got Ichiro (.300 with a .450 SLG second half) out of there, and the M's are pulling off a pitching miracle.

Matty sez he wants game reports.  'till they don't deserve 'em any more, okay.

BABVA,

Dr D

Comments

1

The bullpen is amazing, the defense is amazing, for sure. I trust those squads to keep up the current performance. The starting pitching...? Well, I guess if you believe in Iwakuma... and Millwood... and New Beavan. Me, I'm not sold. Each of these guys has already had a streak this season where they've shown how bad it can get on their off days: Vargas with his June, Iwakuma with his early-season and his long relief stint, Beavan's, uh, whole first half, Millwood's groin tweaks and early season implosions...
Much as I have faith that John Jaso won't keep being the only hitter on this squad--that at least Ackley, Saunders, Seager and Montero will turn it around, that is to say, not that Jaso will hit the skids--I've got no conviction that the starting rotation can keep allowing

2

Between Hisashi+Beavan, and a certified Cone-Radke combo, there is a long, long way...
While they do it, though, the M's are a load... as have been the 2012 Oakland A's, for just so long as their pitchers continue to deliver lockdowns...

3

Has anybody noticed, by the way, that he has 11 starts in for the A's, with a 6.3 / 2.2 / 0.7 three true outcomes so far this year?
Good on yer Travy...

4

The schedule starts to get tough again, after a soft spell filled with Royals, Blue Jays, Twins and (upcoming) Indians.

5
ghost's picture

My call for increased on-field coverage does not mean I'm thinking the Mariners are particularly LIKELY to make the race interesting...it just means I think there's still a chance and I want Doc to fight just as hard as they are fighting. :)
After the Indians/White Sox/Twins chunk, we get 7 against LAA, 7 against Oakland, 6 against Texas, 3 against Toronto, 3 against Boston, and a few others mixed in there. Pretty much the rest of the season after that 4-gamer against the Twinkies is rawhide tough.

7
GLS's picture

Why do you say "the Mariners as an org still find his presence vaguely distasteful"? Where does that come from?

9

... from us.  :- )   From the Mariners, though:
1.  Explicit (not vague) distaste for Johjima-san -- who was an absolutely pitch-perfect teammate and org loyalist
2.  Vague discomfort with Ichiro-san -- who was the only good thing about this org for a decade
3.  Excessive contempt for Iwakuma-san's foreign pitching style in March
4  Contempt for Iwakuma's "soft" style disseminated to public (!) in April
5.  Completely illogical freeze-out of Iwakuma in April and May (when Noesi etc. were getting rocked)
6.  Absolutely no concern over humiliating Mr. WBC by making him throw "garbage" innings in first half
7.  Very sparse and grudging praise of his success since he joined the rotation and pitched brilliantly
8.  Broadcast crew (which always periscopes the org attitude) quick to jump on him for faults ("We knew he'd need a lot of pitches to get through five tonight," "Behind in the count again," "Okay folks now with a runner on first you're really going to see this game slow to a crawl" etc)
9.  Let me know the next time you see anybody in the dugout talking to him, patting him on the back, etc
10.  Broadcast crew very little enthusiasm for his hot roll ("Oh, look what Iwakuma's doing, perfect through four" etc)
11.  If it weren't for SSI would you even know that he's been pitching like an All-Star?
12.  etc
..................
C'mon.  Do you guys still not know a doghouse when you see it?  Or when a guy escapes a doghouse, goes nuts with success, and an org pulls a wry face about it (such as Hargrove with Petagine, for example).
Hey, don't get me wrong.  Americans in Japan have a rougher ride than it goes the other way around.  And we say "vague" distaste because it's not like they hate his guts.  But trust me, if it were Jeff Suppan fanning 8+ men per start they'd be a lot happier about the situation.
They'll quietly endure him, being front and center, precisely as long as he's indisputably one of their best pitchers.  But don't kid yourself that the Johjimas, Ichiros, and Iwakumas get treated warmly here.
 

Add comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><p><br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

shout_filter

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.