BrianL on Ryan Rowland-Smith

Grant me strength to resist the temptation to fault-find all the guys I'm not high on... :- )

ALL these guys have finely-tuned, majestic sports motions.  Hey, the guys in single-A have beautiful sports motions, much less a man like Ryan Rowland-Smith who is one of the 100-200 best in the world at what he does.  (Okay, one of the 300 best, all countries and starters and relievers.  That's still like the number of astronauts there are.)

.

=== Nose-to-Leather ===

Forward Brian's RRS vid to exactly the 15-second mark and tell me at what part of the strike zone that Ryan is looking.

This is not a debatable point.  Have you ever seen a darts champion look away from the board between throws, much less during a throw?  Have you ever seen a skeet shooter gaze off into the forest for a moment between shots?

... RRS' balance over the pitching rubber is perfect.  We know why he looks down; the forward lean balances the torso nicely.

.

=== Fetal Position ===

Go to 26 seconds.  Compactness is a huge plus before the stroke (you have large movements of your limbs available).  Randy Johnson got good, in part, when he started doing a fetal position at this point in the delivery.

.

=== High Front Side ===

:31 to :34 ... I had no idea that RRS pitched with this high of a front side.  The front side hides the ball and promotes the lean-back of the shoulderline to CF, a Japanese secret to engaging your upper-body power and the baseball.

.

=== Deceleration ===

I almost burst into tears.  :43 seconds.

There's no controversy possible about this subject.  There is no sports motion in the free or communist world that benefits from a sudden, crashing deceleration.  Well, maybe there are a couple of golf shots that gain extra spin this way.

True, a lot of ML pitchers do this locked front knee - most of them not as grotesquely.  Pitching coaches are reluctant to fix what ain't broken, I guess.  RRS does have pretty decent control and he manages to get some of his energy released off the right side of the train tracks (notice that he's on the edge of his foot and that his hip is far outside that).

He does focus past the echo-of-the-whistle, so to speak.

.

=== Exec Sum ===

Because of the "praying mantis" coil and unwrap, and the shoulder engagement, RRS has a very powerful motion.  I'm guessing that he gets a lot more out of his arm, relative to his gifts, than a lot of pitchers do.

His command could theoretically benefit from better pre-pitch focus and from smoother deceleration, but, whatever.  He's not going to change at this point.

RRS probably pays the price for his painfully violent deceleration in terms of lower-body and abdominal fatigue.  This could be why he performs badly after pitch 75. Maybe his glutes, abductors, etc., weaken at this point and don't support his motion as well.

As far as the throughstroke, good balance, good leverage, good ki.  He's got the potential for more command and more durability with a coupla tweaks, IMHO.

.

Cheers,

Jeff


Comments

3

It's only a LITTLe high on the backside of his body...but look where his pitching arm is when he cocks the ball...it's pointing down...not up.  That's bad, right?

4
Taro's picture

It only an issue if you have a timing problem and RRS has a pretty big problem there.
His forearm is basically pointing straight down at footplant. Hes very late. High Risk.
It probably a large reason why hes been so fragile.

5

though I agree with Taro that he's 'late' relative to conventional timing.
What is the right amount to stretch the rubber band before you twang it?  RRS holds back the rubber band a bit longer.  He gets more torque as a result, and naturally the extra load creates extra stress on his tissues.
Pitching itself is not good for you.  :- )   What's the right amount of stretch?  The most you can get away with, I guess.
The best analysts are aware that we're all kind of whistling in the dark.  Taro is a believer in the conventional timing, which is cool, and he could well be right.

6

I hadn't read that.  Is that the general consensus now?  That a high upper arm is okay if you don't keep it there very long?
As y'know I am open to all interpretations, but it's just a personal belief with me that the lower the upper-arm angle, the better.  Sidearmers (like Randy Johnson) don't have many shoulder problems.
am not an "inverted W" scourge, but personally believe that sidearm and underhand are the natural human motions, and the farther you get away from that, the worse off you are.  Could be wrong.

7
Taro's picture

No, I mean a high elbow is still bad according to most.
RRS sets his body to the ground before his forearm has rotated to a vertical "upper 90 degree" position, meaning hes rotating the arm over a longer motion in a stress position than an average pitcher would.

8

Understood your point in the second paragraph there.

Add comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><p><br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

shout_filter

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.