.............
Baseball Prospectus' U-25 list marvelled that the M's would run three such impressive big-leaguers -- Felix, Pineda, and Ackley -- out ahead of two 5-star prospects, those being Taijuan and Danny Hultzen. ... Paxton and Franklin were their 4-star guys.
Their list of U-25 talents -- not org prospects, mind yer -- had run,
1 |
Felix, SP
|
2 |
Pineda, SP |
3 |
Ackley |
4 |
Taijuan, SP |
5 |
Hultzen, SP
|
6 |
Paxton, SP |
7 |
Trayvon |
8 |
Franklin |
9 |
Smoak |
10 |
Carp |
To me it was even more impressive that Carp and Smoak would be 9 and 10 on their list.
One thing is clear: it is hiiiiiiiiigh blinkin' time for Seattle fans to lose their "No Cheering In the Press Box," more-objective-than-thou attitude about the Mariners' young talent. It is time to enthuse about the M's young talent.
Zduriencik has earned several times his salary in this arena. Hey, he's probably earned several times his salary with the Justin Smoak trade alone. He probably earned it again with the Danny Hultzen draft choice.
..........
Not thinking about it too much, I wonder whether Felix would even be #1 on such a list, because of the Net Value factor.
My idea on an U-25 list is this. "Suppose that the two new expansion MLB teams could take ANYbody off your roster but one player, who would you protect?"
And then, "Suppose they could take anybody but two players, who would you protect?" And so on.
From my standpoint, the Baseball America-style org prospect rankings often make little sense. Many times I would protect the #5 org prospect before I'd protect the #1, but they're thinking about one side of the "production rectangle" or the other -- emphasizing either chance to succeed (Seager) or upside (Taijuan).