.
In his 2012 "Dynasties" article, James had written,
.
1947-1964
68 points. The Greatest Dynasty of All Time.
Key Figures: Casey Stengel, Mickey Mantle, Yogi Berra, Whitey Ford, Roger Maris
In terms of personnel, the 1947-1964 Yankees are no match for the Ruth and Gehrig Yankees. The Ruth/Gehrig Yankees have a Hall of Fame catcher (Dickey), one of the greatest first basemen ever (Gehrig), two Hall of Fame second basemen (Lazzeri and Gordon), a Hall of Fame shortstop (Rizzuto), at least three Hall of Fame outfielders (Ruth, DiMaggio, and Earle Combs), and at least four Hall of Fame pitchers (Gomez, Ruffing, Pennock and Waite Hoyt.) All the 1947-1964 Yankees have is Mantle, Berra, Ford, and the second half of Phil Rizzuto’s career.
But in terms of dominance on the field, the 1947-1964 team accomplished more in 18 years than the 1920-1943 team did in 24. Ruth and Gehrig were in the Yankee lineup together for ten years, and won four pennants. Mantle and Berra were in the Yankee lineup together for eleven years, and won nine pennants. They dominated their league—and the other league—to a greater extent than any other team ever has.
.....
And you click through the almanac ... the thing that jumps out at you is that the 1947-1964 clubs had their superduperstars at C and CF, not at RF and 1B. The 1947-64 teams then did a really good job of "Stars & Scrubs Fungibility" -- making sure that the other 6 lineups spots had decent players in them, with no gaps.