Winter 2011-12 -- The Bar in the AL West
....
Q. Okay, each year half the teams make the postseason with about +75 differential. Does this mean that the 2012 Mariners are contenders if they hit +75?
A. No.
For the Mariners, the target is more like +100. Maybe even a bit more.
The AL Wild Card the last five years has been won by Boston, New York and once the Tigers, with run differentials of +140 to +190 runs every cotton-pickin', chicken-pluckin' year. If you want to shoot for the wild card in the American League, you better pencil in 95 wins, bro'.
So the Mariners have to factor in the reality that the Wild Card is a no go, not unless they become a truly powerful team. To win the AL Wild Card, you frequently have to be (pretty much) the 2nd-best team in baseball.
That ain't happenin'. Not unless you got like three more Pinedas in the minor leagues somewhere.
....