Why Doesn't Ichiro bat 3rd?

The Seattle Times round table forum with the other beat writers raised some interesting issues. As they say: If you really want to know what's up, find out what your opponents think of you.  Who is the most feared hitter in the AL West?  Ichiro.


What does 200 hits mean a year?  Well, not too much, if it just means getting on first or second base 200 times.

One of the beat writers had the idea that Ichiro should bat third in the lineup, and transfer all of those marvelous hits into RBIs.

Here's a theory: walks and hits are equal when the bases are empty, but hits become more valuable the more loaded the bases are.  With the bases loaded and two outs, you would rather have a hit than a walk, because of a better chance of scoring two runs on a single or three runs on a double.  I'm sure someone already thought of this and I am reinventing the wheel.

So, here we have Figgins, who walks well, is speedy, and does not hit nearly as much as Ichiro available for leadoff.  Why not put him in the 1 hole, Lopez or Gutierrez in the 2 hole and have Ichiro clean house while people are on base?

In 2009, Ichiro went to base 297 times and only scored 88 times.  He only had 46 RBIs.

By comparison, Chone figgins made base 242 times with 114 runs and 54 RBI.

Both players have an on base percentage hovering under 400.

Ichiro, as deployed, is no more valuable than Chone Figgins when it comes to the bottom line.

Ichiro, as he could be deployed, would have some serious opportunites to knock in runs.

Why are the M's squandering hall of fame talent?

 

Klat Categories: 

Comments

Ichiro could also compound the offense with talented hitters in front of him, because he is the game's best situational hitter.

Do you need a pop fly? Ichiro could give you one whenever he felt like it.

Do you need power? Ichiro could hit for power if it was necessary.

Do you need a bunt? Ichiro is the best bunter in the league.

All of these skills are under utilized and impotent because the Mariners only place scrubs on the back end of the lineup.

Where did Ty Cobb hit in the Detroit lineup? Leadoff?

NO!

Number three, and he hit approximately 90 RBI's per year.

What could the M's do with 50 more runs?

 

1

Ichiro needs hitters with wheels to hit in front of him, so that those sharp singles are not turned into double plays.  The man for the two hole would be Franklin Gutierrez.  He hits as well, and for as much power as J-Lo, and with a whole lot more speed under him.

That would make three monster base stealer/runners in a row, giving you a dillinger, Skilling, Madoff offense before the big bats (Who are they?) come up.

This has the makings of a not-so small ball offense.

2

And why don't we just throw Ackley into the lineup now, as is, without further development?

Surely he can hit better than Rob Johnson, or Jack Wilson.

He is another one of those speedy guys with good hits, walks, average and power.  That's what the M's need isn't it?

How about sending Lopez to SS, sending Ackley to 2nd, and then having four speedy guys in a row, with Ackley hitting ninth until he proved otherwise.

We don't need to stress defense to the tune of an automatic out when something better is in the works.

Felix and Cliff don't need a shortstop, they can just concentrate a little harder and strike more people out.

3

Anonymous's picture

Anonymous

I think the biggest issue is that Ichiro likes batting leadoff.  There is one other issue that concerns me, which is all the slow rollers Ichiro hits for base hits.  A lot of the balls in play that get recorded as hits for Ichiro in the leadoff spot will become fielders choices in the 2-hole (and lead to a lot of outs as well).  As fast as Figgins is, it's really hard to make it to second on one of Ichiro's patented "oh my god how did he beat that out" slow-rollers to the middle-infield.  That's a huge deal, because Ichiro had 50 infield hits last year, and hasn't had fewer than 40 since 2005.  If Figgins is on base ~40% of the time Ichiro's batting behind him, and ~65% of the time he's standing on first, a lot of Ichiro's value is negated (potentially as many as 1/4 to 1/3 of his infield hits).  If he's third, it's the same deal with runners on 1B and 2B.

I haven't entirely convinced myself, but it's something to think about.  I'm not going to lie, part of my hesitation has to do with hoping against hope he makes it to 3000 hits as a major leaguer and not wanting to see anything happen that lessens that possibility.

4

But then I looked at Ichiro's B-Ref Splits:

Bases empty: 331/361/438

Men On:  336/409/426

Man On First:  331/359/431

 

With nearly identical BABiPs...Ichiro adapts and runs the same line no matter what

5

I agree that Ichiro's 200 hits per season could be ruined if he batted lower in the lineup from fielder's choice plays at second base.

But, Ichiro's speediness in the three hole would be better for the team.

I would like to offer into evidence what will be known as Plaintiff's Exhibit A:

Mariners 2009 team leaders in  double plays:

Jose Lopez, 25 GIDP

Adrian Beltre, 19 GIDP

Least on team:

Ichiro, 1 GIDP

The mariners hit into 128 double plays in 2009, and a full 34 percent of those were caused by Lopez and Beltre, the three and four hitters, respectively.

As was posted the other week, there seems to be severe consequences to allowing slow people in the batter's box.

Lopez makes up for his GIDP crimes with 90 RBIs, but Beltre only had 46 RBIs.  It makes me appreciate how much Chone Figgins for Beltre has improved the club.  Now if we can just get our little Ichiro Clones, F-Gut and Ackley, reaching their potentials, the Mariners will have to be renamed for something that is fast, dangerous and ill tempered.  The Black Marlins? Already taken.  The Eagles? Already taken.  How about the Seattle Salmon Sharks?

How about Ackley being listed on the Mariners' Web site as a first base man.

Last time I checked, the Mariners were lacking a defined first base man.

Ackley if given the chance, could out hit, out field and out run Garko, Kotchman and whoever else we have at first base.  Also, Ackley needs to play in the bigs before Ichiro retires so that Ichiro can teach him his samurai stuff.

Regards,

Mojician.

6

Another thing, 

Regarding Ichiro hitting into a fielder's choice,

Shouldn't Figgins and F-Gut have already thieved their way into scoring position by the time Ichiro comes to bat?  Those bloop singles look awfully good when there is a man on third base.

Regards,

Mojician

7

Anonymous's picture

Anonymous

Gomez of Dead Cats Bounce has performed some useful analysis on average plate appearances based on position (see here).  He argues that in moving Ichiro to 3rd or 4th, you penalise him somewhere between 40-60 plate apperances which in turn - would equate to about 15-20 hits over a full season.

I would be interested to know whether you could place a comparative value on the hits lost (Ichiro scores a run about once every 2.5-3 on-base visits so potentially you lose 5-7 runs) versus the potential runs gained by having Ichiro batting runners in (who given their speed, may well be in scoring position). 

And this would of course have to be compared with the alternative of keeping Ichiro at first with Figgins 2nd etc.

Are there simulators that could tell you a likely run differential by changing the order of the lineup?

8

Shoutbox

Please log in or create an account to post shouts.
SABR MattHappy pi day, everyone! 3/14/15, 9:26:53 enjoy some pie. :)3 hours 50 min ago
SpectatorWilson had the best SLG of any prospect who didn't play at High Desert, but he grades out as strong BA and OBP guy too. And he looks like Megatron. And he went to Stanford for the academics (both his parents have Ph.D.s). What's not to like?17 hours 25 min ago
Gordon GrossWilson can run, though. He's one of my most anticipated minor leaguers this season. His swing is looking good and compact, especially for a big man. If he's healthy, I wanna see if he can take a Winfield-sized step forward into harnessing all those tools.19 hours 4 min ago
Gordon GrossAustin didn't even get a pitch worth swinging at. Throw him a strike at least, ya bum! ;)19 hours 6 min ago
Gordon GrossLara showing off his arm. That's always fun. :) He reminds me of Mike Wilson a bit. Big guy, more athletic than he looks, good arm, not bad at the plate... Mike just stopped progressing as a player at a relatively young age, and then stopped caring. We'll see if Lara can keep making progress. He doesn't exactly have a lightning-quick bat, so that hand-eye and pitch-reading better be sharp.19 hours 11 min ago
Gordon GrossMan, I'd love to see Wilson get into one. He's way above his current level, since he'll be starting off in AA at BEST, maybe the Cal League. But that guy can rake when he's right, and his more compact swing he found in the MWL last year is pretty. I have huge hopes for that dude if he can stay healthy.19 hours 15 min ago
Gordon GrossYup. Still don't like Guiape yet. Medina minus a foot on his fastball.19 hours 18 min ago
SpectatorAn Austin Wilson sighting! Let's hope he stays healthy and fast-tracks! He could end up being better than D.J. or Kivlehan.19 hours 34 min ago
SABR MattBTW re: Happ's velocity...the gun looks a little soft at Peoria. Most of the guys are recording velocities that seem low to me. Farquhar throwing 93 tops, Smith topping out at 91.19 hours 39 min ago
SABR MattYeah Spec...unless you see a pitcher who is a legit .260+ hitter, the hitting doesn't matter much and the fielding...it matters, but the guys who are great fielders are mostly the guys who need to be...the guys who are terrible fielders are mostly the guys who don't need to field much.19 hours 40 min ago
SpectatorThanks for the answers Matt. So not really worth fussing with unless as "all else being equal" situation.19 hours 59 min ago
Gordon GrossCarson Smith usually looks wild. He's gonna be a Jeff Nelson type. As long as he doesn't give up hits it'll be all right.20 hours 13 min ago
Gordon GrossCarson Smith: wiping dudes out with that slider and fielding pretty darn well also. Him running to 2nd to take the throw from Miller was nice.20 hours 15 min ago
SABR Matteasy 1-2-3 inning for Carson Smith...but he looked very wild to me.20 hours 16 min ago
SABR MattAs some here might know, when I created DNRA back in the day, I treated balls fielded by the pitcher as "DIPS" plays and gave full credit to the pitcher for the out. The difference between Jamie Moyer and Randy Johnson was usually about 25-30 extra fielded balls for Moyer. That's worth like 5 runs above a "random" grounder. So...not zero...but small. :) As for hitting...there are very few pitchers that gain more than a few tenths of a win for offense these days...though that was not always true.20 hours 20 min ago
Gordon GrossSingles from Zunino make me weirdly happy. He's gonna hit 20 bombs. He needs more singles.20 hours 25 min ago
SpectatorHad this question in the Hultzen comments. Matt, is there any evidence on how much a picther can gain "bonus value" from fielding? or hitting in NL parks? or is it just pretty much de minimis?20 hours 25 min ago
GLSThat's too bad about Darvish. Hate to see great players like that go down.20 hours 28 min ago
SpectatorHapp's fastball famously went from 91 avg to 93 avg in '14. Just going off Gameday, seems like he's averaging 91 today.20 hours 30 min ago
SABR MattEnjoying this game live...Mariners doing a nice job putting good ABs on Fiers...20 hours 35 min ago