Spring Training Buzz, Sweeney vs Garko

Subscribe to Comments for "Spring Training Buzz, Sweeney vs Garko"

Replies

moe's picture
Submitted by moe on

There appears to be an error (unless I'm missing something obvious) in Garko's vs. LH starters. b-ref shows he has 20 more PA's against LH starters than he does against all LH pitchers. Odd.

jemanji's picture
Submitted by jemanji on

They've got his games, and apparently K/BB, right, but then the PA's are wrong.

"as sub" they've got him 1-for-23 with an .043 SLG last year, so if that's anywhere near right, then I'd still have to give him credit for being even more effective as a platoon starter than his overall #'s show...

Or not...

moe's picture
Submitted by moe on

You know...the more I look at it and the more I think about it the more it looks like Garko is the odd man out.

Sweeney is WAY mashing the ball. He can play 1B. He's RH. He stays.

Lopez can play 1B. He's RH. He stays.

Kotchman is a gloveman and was brought in for two reasons...because he's a gloveman and he hits lefty. He's going to stay.

Tui, I imagine can play 1B, in a pinch. He's going to stay.

That's 4 guys who can play 1B (assuming Tuui can...which makes great sense)...3 are RH.

Garko is redundant.

BTW...Tui played SS today with Felix pitching. That's pretty much an announcement that he's staying up.

So....I'm figuring that the most likely lineup on Opening Day (barring a trade and assuming a RHP is up) is Ichiro, Figgins, Bradley, Lopez, Jr., Guti, Kotchman, Johnson, Wilson.....

And I'm assuming that Tui, Moore, Byrnes are on the roster...and I'm assuming that they keep 12 pitchers...so who is the one remaining position player? Part of that might be whoever can be an emergency catcher. (BTW..Garko caught in the minors...last time was in '06..but if you keep Garko...then you basically have 3 guys who who are basically DH/1B...Hannahan might be the better keep)

For whatever it's worth.

Keith

jemanji's picture
Submitted by jemanji on

[[ BTW...Tui played SS today with Felix pitching. ]]

c-points

Leave a Reply

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.