You are here

POTD Jonny Gomes

Replies

Taro's picture
Submitted by Taro on

I like Gomes' profit potential with the bat, but hes a REAALY poor defender in the OF. So much so that I don't think he fits as a 4th outfielder type.

If the Ms strike out on their DH alternatives and are looking for a guy to share DH with Griffey? Sure...he'd be another fallback plan though since hes not the greatest Safeco fit.

jemanji's picture
Submitted by jemanji on

At what point is a player so inept that he shouldn't be on the field.  :shrug:

I grew up with guys like Greg Luzinski, Boog Powell and Dave Kingman playing, so to me when people nowadays say that Raul Ibanez is an embarrassment who shouldn't own a glove, it sounds a bit extreme...

Once again, I note that Gomez runs well -- very good SX scores for a left fielder, e.g. 16 SB's all levels in 2007 -- so my first question is the proof that he's a bad left fielder, before I ask whether he's a laughingstock in LF.

....

I notice that on the Fans' Scouting Report, Gomes is rated above Johnny Damon, Delmon Young, and a bunch of guys...

If Gomes were here, you wouldn't be talking about his playing 140 games in left.  You're talking more like 40 games in left, perhaps on days when groundball pitchers are out there, if necessary.

.....

In general, I hate to see ballplayers labeled "can't be allowed on the field" so easily.  

With Cust or Dunn, fine.  But if Jonny Gomes can't be allowed on the field, well, there are about 70 starting players on FSR ranked lower than Gomes, who also shouldn't be on the field, I guess....

jemanji's picture
Submitted by jemanji on

If you (and Capt Jack, and whoever) sees Gomes as a DH only... then, yeah, you're looking at a DH who gives you the kind of offense that Sweeney did in the 2H last year...

Would agree that if he's DH only, he's a fallback plan... would much prefer somebody who can help in the field.  Agree 100%.

............

Of course, these fallback plans get taken off the board quickly, as Gomes easily could be...

..............

Personally would only want Gomes -- as a LF'er -- if 1B was going to be Your Big Move.  Like with Gonzalez.

Taro's picture
Submitted by Taro on

Ya, I agree with that.. I can see Gomes in that role sharing PAs with Griffey.

I can't really see him in the OF, even part-time (only in an emergency when the offense is slumping big-time).. I think if Z gets him, hes thinking DH.

Taro's picture
Submitted by Taro on

Fans scouting reports have him as a putrid defender...

I think you move a player down the defensive spectrum when a player is bad enough in the field that it cancels out his contributions with the bat.

Ibanez is poor glove at this point, but good enough that you can play him in the field in a non-spacious park without him losing much value.. Gomes is really, really bad.

Anonymous's picture
Submitted by Anonymous on

The Power.. And the .400 OBP career in the minors. Last year was actually a pretty poor season for Gomes as he didn't hit that well in AAA. He's also been .372 OBP in the majors in the past....

I don't know but I could see Gomes hit 50 hr given 650 Plate Appeareance. Just let him play everyday... If that means putting him in OF behind 3rd then put him behind 3b. He'll be good enough...

 

Leave a Reply

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <ul> <ol> <li> <i> <b> <img> <table> <tr> <td> <th> <div> <strong> <p> <br> <u>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.